Mithrandir Metrics
Diagnostic ATH Refreshed Aug 31 06:00 AM ET
Optimization diagnostic / ATH

Mason Barnett

Mason Barnett's tools (51) outpace production (32) by 19 points. Primary finding: changeup grades as the best pitch (whiff 50.0%, csw 16.7%) but is only thrown 14.5% of the time. Also flagged: Arsenal Shape: Gloveside Drop; Usage Overuse: 4-Seam Fastball. Most actionable fix: increase changeup usage to at least league-average for that pitch type.

Score
69
Tools
51
Gap
+18.8
Data window 2026-08-17 / 2026-08-31Confidence MEDIUM
Optimization map

Arsenal shape map

Hover each pitch to inspect current usage, movement shape, and whiff context beside the written diagnosis.

View arsenal in 3D →
ride armside gloveside
Movement reshape

Pitch movement dual-view

Current shape against the recommended movement window. Animation starts when this section scrolls into view.

CurveballArsenal Shape: Gloveside Drop
Δ HB -11.4in · Δ VB +6.1in
Top-down · horizontal break Side view · vertical break
Current: HB 8.4in / VB -14.1in Recommended: HB -3.0in / VB -8.0in
Diagnosis

Fixable gaps

SignalCauseFixConfidence
Stuff-to-Whiff Gap (Command)0.49Elite stuff tunnels well but pitches land in hittable zonesReduce heart-of-zone pitches; increase edge and chase attemptsBetter location could push whiff rate toward 24%+MEDIUM
Arsenal Shape: Gloveside Drop0.60Existing Curveball is present, but its movement shape does not currently cover the desired gloveside-drop window.Reshape existing Curveball to add gloveside drop rather than developing a new pitch from scratch.Shape refinement would improve platoon coverage while preserving the existing usage signal.HIGH
Usage Underuse: Changeup0.70Changeup grades as the best pitch (whiff 50.0%, CSW 16.7%) but is only thrown 14.5% of the timeIncrease Changeup usage to at least league-average for that pitch typeUsage rebalancing is the simplest optimization with immediate impactMEDIUM
Usage Overuse: 4-Seam Fastball0.604-Seam Fastball grades as the weakest pitch (whiff 12.0%, CSW 17.3%) but is thrown 62.6% of the timeReduce 4-Seam Fastball usage in favor of higher-performing offeringsUsage rebalancing is the simplest optimization with immediate impactMEDIUM
Arsenal / metrics

Underlying components

ComponentUsageVeloWhiff
4-Seam FastballFF63%94.712.0%
ChangeupCH14%84.250.0%
SliderSL10%87.30.0%
SweeperST7%83.850.0%
CurveballCU6%78.00.0%